SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER
Maxwell v. Dinis, and what the justices asked about First Step Act credits
Supreme Court of the United States, No. 25-5930.
Argued November 2, 2026. Decision pending.
William Maxwell is a federal prisoner serving a 240-month sentence. (Gov't Br. 4.) The Supreme Court's docket lists his address as FCI Beaumont in Texas. (Docket, party information.) In 2022, representing himself, he filed a habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2241 in the Eastern District of Texas. He said the Bureau of Prisons had not given him the First Step Act time credits he had earned, and that those credits should already have moved him to a halfway house or home confinement. (Gov't Br. 12.)
The respondent is Sandra Dinis, Acting Warden. The docket caption is William Maxwell, Petitioner v. Sandra Dinis, Acting Warden. (Docket.)
What the case is about
The Supreme Court agreed to decide one question: whether a claim about how First Step Act time credits are applied, when the prisoner is asking for an earlier move to a halfway house or home confinement, can be brought in a habeas petition under § 2241. (Docket, order of June 1, 2026; Question Presented.)
The district court dismissed Mr. Maxwell's petition after finding he had not exhausted the BOP's administrative remedy process. (Gov't Br. 12.) The Fifth Circuit affirmed on a different ground. It said that because a halfway house or home confinement would not "entitle him to accelerated release," his claim belonged in a civil-rights suit, not in habeas. (Gov't Br. 13, quoting J.A. 35.)
In the Supreme Court, the government agrees with Mr. Maxwell that the Fifth Circuit got the habeas question wrong, and it asks the Court to vacate the judgment. (Gov't Br. 3; Tr. 43:1–9.) No party defended the Fifth Circuit's reasoning, so the Court invited a lawyer, Brian W. Barnes, to argue as amicus curiae in support of the judgment below. (Docket, June 16, 2026.) The Court split the argument time three ways. (Docket, Oct. 13, 2026; SG Motion for Divided Argument.)
What happened at the argument
Masha G. Hansford, arguing for Mr. Maxwell, told the Court that he is being held in prison in violation of federal law because the First Step Act requires that he be moved to home confinement or a halfway house. She described that placement as a "distinct and lower level of custody." (Tr. 3:11–16.) She also noted that "[n]o one defends" the Fifth Circuit's rule. (Tr. 4:6.)
Justice Thomas did not wait for the merits. He asked about the government's review-bar argument, exhaustion, and "the possible mootness problem." (Tr. 5:6–11.) Ms. Hansford said the case is not moot because Mr. Maxwell is still in custody. She added that even if he is released before the Court rules, restoring his credits could still matter, because he would argue they should shorten his supervised release. She acknowledged that the circuits disagree on that point. (Tr. 7:6–8:9.) On exhaustion, she said that issue should be decided on remand, and that the Fifth Circuit had dismissed the case on its own ("sua sponte") on the habeas ground. (Tr. 8:13–9:18.)
Justice Jackson said the question before the Court seemed "very narrow" and asked whether the Court really needed to "define every circumstance in which habeas is appropriate." (Tr. 10:9–25.) Ms. Hansford said Mr. Maxwell was "happy with a narrow rule." (Tr. 11:2–3.) Justice Jackson then said a narrow ruling "would be helpful because this kind of situation comes up a lot." (Tr. 12:6–8.)
Kevin J. Barber, Assistant to the Solicitor General, agreed with Mr. Maxwell on the main question. If Mr. Maxwell has "any avenue" for his First Step Act claim, Barber said, "habeas is the one." He called prerelease custody "a modern version of federal parole." (Tr. 20:1–20.) Then he asked the Court to consider the review bar in 18 U.S.C. § 3621(b) and "the impending mootness of this case." (Tr. 20:21–25.) He suggested the Court could dismiss the case as improvidently granted, which lawyers call a "DIG." (Tr. 22:25–23:4.)
That suggestion was already in the government's papers. Its merits brief, filed August 5, 2026, asked the Court to consider a DIG and explained that BOP projected Mr. Maxwell would become eligible for a halfway house on January 22, 2027, based on 1,275 days of credits. (Gov't Br. 3, 14, 16, 41.) The October reply brief made the same request. (Gov't Reply Br. 21.) At argument, Mr. Barber said the government had "floated the idea of a DIG in our papers." (Tr. 28:8–9.) Mr. Maxwell's reply brief called the request "a mulligan" and argued the case would stay live either way. (Pet. Reply Br. 19–20.)
Justice Kavanaugh asked why the § 3621(b) issue could not simply be left for remand. (Tr. 28:1–2.) Justice Barrett asked whether the government was claiming the review bar took away the Court's power to decide the question presented. Mr. Barber said no. He agreed the Court "totally could" decide the habeas question and leave the review bar for the Fifth Circuit, and he called that choice "a discretionary call." (Tr. 32:21–33:20.)
Justice Alito saw it differently. He asked whether it was "prudent" to decide the question when the review bar might end up barring these claims anyway, and whether a ruling would have any practical effect on Mr. Maxwell. Mr. Barber said it would not, and that the "more prudent course" would be a DIG. (Tr. 34:1–35:2.) Justice Jackson pointed out that Mr. Maxwell's projected date was "like the end of January," which left time for a ruling. (Tr. 35:3–12.)
Justice Jackson then said the DIG argument "sounds like we are re-litigating certiorari," and asked whether the government had raised these points when the Court decided to take the case. (Tr. 35:17–36:1.) Mr. Barber answered: "We did not raise mootness or 3621(b) at the cert stage. We should have done so." (Tr. 36:3–4.) Justice Jackson explained that a DIG usually happens when something unexpected keeps the Court from reaching the question. She said the government's new issue was "being floated to undermine our consideration of the question that is presented." (Tr. 36:9–21.)
Mr. Barber kept asking for a DIG. He also said: "This is a complication that wasn't brought up in the cert papers. That was our bad. We apologize for that." (Tr. 37:4–6.)
Justice Alito asked whether there is a rule that the Court cannot dismiss a case after briefing and argument when it has "a very severe case of buyer's regret." The transcript notes laughter. (Tr. 37:15–22.) Mr. Barber said there is no such rule. (Tr. 37:23–25.) Justice Sotomayor responded, "But you want to win on an argument that you failed to raise on cert?" and, after Mr. Barber started to answer, "That's what you want to do. Enough." (Tr. 38:3–8.) Justice Gorsuch then said, "I haven't heard 'my bad' before at the podium," and, after more laughter, "Good on you." (Tr. 38:11–14.)
Justice Gorsuch gave Mr. Barber a chance to answer Ms. Hansford's argument that the credits could still shorten supervised release. Mr. Barber said that argument "lacks all merit" and could not keep the case alive. (Tr. 38:15–39:25.) He noted the January 22, 2027 projected date and suggested that if the Court rules before then, it should issue its judgment "forthwith." (Tr. 40:5–10.) Justice Gorsuch put it this way: "even if it's not moot here, it's going to be moot down there real quick." Mr. Barber answered, "Absolutely, yes." (Tr. 40:12–15.)
Mr. Barnes, the Court-appointed amicus, argued that prerelease custody is not "release," because people in a halfway house or on home confinement remain under BOP control. In his view, that puts the claim on the "conditions of confinement side of the line." (Tr. 45:9–20; 47:9–13.) On mootness, he said he was "hard-pressed to see a strong argument" that the case would matter to Mr. Maxwell after transfer, but that this was "not necessarily a reason" to DIG. (Tr. 64:7–14.)
In rebuttal, Ms. Hansford started "with the DIG discussion." (Tr. 68:13–14.) She argued that a DIG would encourage parties to come up with new threshold barriers after the Court grants review (Tr. 69:5–8), that Mr. Maxwell intends to keep litigating the supervised-release issue if he is moved to a halfway house (Tr. 69:9–13), and that there is "no reason for this Court to have buyer's remorse on this case." (Tr. 69:15–16.)
Where it stands
The case was submitted at the end of the argument on November 2, 2026. (Tr. 70:21–22; Docket.) As of November 9, 2026, the docket shows no decision. The Court could decide the habeas question, vacate and send the case back, or dismiss it. We are not going to guess which. The justices' questions show what they were thinking about that day, not how they will vote.
Why this matters
Many people in federal prison believe the BOP has miscounted their First Step Act credits. Whether those claims can be brought in a § 2241 habeas petition affects where they can file and how quickly a judge can look at the numbers. Ms. Hansford told the Court that prisoners in two large circuits are being told to bring these claims as Bivens civil-rights suits instead. (Tr. 18:18–21.) The government agrees that this claim is not a Bivens claim. (Tr. 43:9.) Even if Mr. Maxwell wins on the habeas question, the government's § 3621(b) review-bar argument and his exhaustion dispute would still be waiting on remand. (Gov't Br. 3; Tr. 8:13–9:18.)
Practical steps
The Supreme Court has not ruled. Until it does, courts still apply their own circuit's law.
Use the BOP grievance process, and name the First Step Act. Mr. Maxwell's petition was first dismissed for failure to exhaust. The district court said his grievances did not mention his First Step Act credits as the reason he should be moved. (Gov't Br. 12, quoting J.A. 31.) Name the statute and the credits in every administrative request.
Keep the paperwork. The government's own figures came from Mr. Maxwell's BOP "FSA Time Credit Assessment" and his inmate "program review." (Gov't Br. 14.) Families can help by keeping copies of every assessment, program review, and BOP response.
These claims usually arise near the end of a sentence, which is why mootness came up. (Tr. 17:22–18:6.) If a credit dispute could change a transfer date, raise it early and talk with a lawyer about where and how to file.
We will post an update when the Court rules.
Sources
Supreme Court docket, No. 25-5930: https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/25-5930.html
Official oral argument transcript (Nov. 2, 2026), cited "Tr. page:line": https://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/argument_transcripts/2026/25-5930_bqmd.pdf
Question presented: https://www.supremecourt.gov/qp/25-05930qp.pdf
Brief for the Respondent Supporting Vacatur (Aug. 5, 2026), cited "Gov't Br.": https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/25/25-5930/418232/20260805174545194_25-5930UnitedStates.pdf
Reply Brief for the Respondent (Oct. 19, 2026), cited "Gov't Reply Br.": https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/25/25-5930/430007/20261019165858091_25-5930_Maxwell_usrb.pdf
Reply Brief for Petitioner (Oct. 19, 2026), cited "Pet. Reply Br.": https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/25/25-5930/429966/20261019143126980_25-5930MaxwellReplyBrief.pdf
SG Motion for Divided Argument (Sept. 23, 2026): https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/25/25-5930/425358/20260923130718564_25-5930_Maxwell_Div_Arg.pdf
SamaritanConsultants@Gmail.com Corrlinks
SP@NorridLaw.com Corrlinks
SamaritanProjects.com Website
816 562 4981 or 417 236 1179
Samaritan Consultants
"When No One Else Will Help, We Will!"

Comments