SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER
He Was Told 21 Years. The Real Floor Was 57 Years.
A Court Said That Bad Advice Cost Him a Fair Choice.
What happened:
In 2010, federal prosecutors charged Steven Baker with robbing a credit union in Neptune, New Jersey, and with a gun count under 18 U.S.C. § 924(c) (slip op. at 2). The government offered a deal. Baker would plead to those two counts and admit two other robberies, and in exchange he wouldn't be charged with them (slip op. at 4). His lawyer told him the plea meant roughly 15 to 17 years. She also told him that if he went to trial and was convicted on three gun counts, those counts would add 21 years, 7 for each count (slip op. at 4–6).
The 21-year figure was wrong. Under the § 924(c) "stacking" rule in effect then, the second and third gun counts each carried a 25-year mandatory minimum on top of the first count's 7 years. That made a 57-year mandatory minimum (slip op. at 6–7, citing Deal v. United States, 508 U.S. 129 (1993)). Baker turned the deal down, went to trial, and was convicted on every count. He got 57 years on the gun counts plus 87 months on the robberies (slip op. at 8). That comes to just over 64 years.
The First Step Act of 2018 later ended that kind of stacking for people convicted of several § 924(c) counts in a single case. But Congress didn't make the change retroactive for sentences that were already final, and Baker's was (slip op. at 7 & n.3).
The long road through § 2255:
Baker filed a § 2255 motion on his own in January 2014. That first motion did not raise the stacking-advice claim (slip op. at 9). The court appointed counsel in 2016, and a federal public defender later raised the claim. The district court held an evidentiary hearing in July 2021 (slip op. at 9–10). The court found that the lawyer had given Baker wrong advice about stacking. It assumed, without actually deciding, that her performance was deficient. It then denied relief on the ground that Baker hadn't shown prejudice (slip op. at 11).
What the Third Circuit held
The appeals court reversed (slip op. at 3, 32).
Deficient performance: The stacking rule was "established and longstanding." Getting a defendant's exposure this wrong fell below an objective standard of reasonableness (slip op. at 14–15).
Prejudice: Under Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668 (1984), and Lafler v. Cooper, 566 U.S. 156 (2012), Baker only had to show a reasonable probability that he would have taken the plea if he'd been advised correctly (slip op. at 15). The court said the gap between 15 to 17 years and a 57-year floor "weighs heavily in favor of prejudice." It credited Baker's testimony that he would have pleaded, finding the district court's contrary credibility ruling clearly erroneous (slip op. at 15, 19, 31). The court also explained why Baker's claims of innocence after he rejected the plea counted for little. He testified that he had admitted guilt to his lawyer before trial, and she corroborated that (slip op. at 30–31).
Remedy: The case went back with instructions to order the government to reoffer the original plea. If Baker accepted, the district court would decide the right remedy (slip op. at 32, citing Lafler, 566 U.S. at 174).
What happened next:
Baker took a new plea in fall 2024, was resentenced on November 25, 2024, to 194 months, and was released that month. The Bureau of Prisons inmate locator does list Baker, released November 27, 2024.
Practical steps
Rebuild the advice you got. Write down what your lawyer said your exposure was, both with the plea and at trial. Ask for the lawyer's notes. In Baker, the lawyer's handwritten "7-7-7" note helped prove what she had told him (slip op. at 5–6).
Compare that advice with the law in force at the time. Look especially at mandatory minimums, stacking, and enhancements.
Show the gap. A large difference between the plea and your real exposure was the heart of the prejudice ruling (slip op. at 18–19).
Be ready to explain any claims of innocence. If you maintained innocence after the plea deadline because your lawyer told you to, or if you admitted guilt to your lawyer privately, say so and back it up (slip op. at 30).
Mind timeliness. A § 2255 motion generally must be filed within one year, measured from one of the starting points in 28 U.S.C. § 2255(f). In Baker, the government challenged timeliness in the district court but did not press it on appeal (slip op. at 11 & n.6). Get help early.
Why this matters:
Deciding whether to take a plea may be the biggest decision in a federal case. You can't make that decision well if your lawyer gets the numbers badly wrong. In Baker v. United States, 109 F.4th 187 (3d Cir. 2024), the Third Circuit held that a lawyer's huge mistake about mandatory minimums was enough to undo a § 2255 denial. The case is a good model for anyone who turned down a plea on advice that turned out to be wrong.
Sources:
Baker v. United States, No. 23-2059, 109 F.4th 187 (3d Cir. July 25, 2024) (precedential): https://www2.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/232059p.pdf ; Justia: https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca3/23-2059/23-2059-2024-07-25.html ; reporter cite confirmed at OpenJurist: https://openjurist.org/109/f4th/187/steven-baker-v-united-states
Baker v. United States, No. 3:14-cv-00370 (D.N.J.), district court filings on GovInfo: https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USCOURTS-njd-3_14-cv-00370
Federal Bureau of Prisons Inmate Locator (search "Steven Baker"; result: Steven L. Baker, 60896-050, released 11/27/2024): https://www.bop.gov/inmateloc/
28 U.S.C. § 2255: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/2255
SP@NorridLaw.com Corrlinks
SamaritanConsultants@Gmail.com Corrlinks
SamaritanProjects.com Website
816 562 4981 or 417 236 1179
Samaritan Consultants
"When No One Else Will Help, We Will!"

Comments