top of page
Search

SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER

Nov 3
4 min read

"Let the BOP Handle It" Was the Wrong Answer: The Fifth Circuit on Credit for Related State Time


Why this matters:

Many people with both state and federal cases assume that the BOP will automatically count the time they've already served. Often it can't. A new published Fifth Circuit decision, United States v. Koan, No. 25-10850 (5th Cir. Oct. 2, 2026), explains why. It also explains what a sentencing judge can do about it.


What happened:

David Koan pleaded guilty in federal court to two counts of producing child pornography under 18 U.S.C. § 2251(a). He had already been sentenced to 35 years in Texas for aggravated sexual assault of a child, and the federal offense grew out of the same conduct (slip op. at 2). By the time of federal sentencing he had served 39 months and 28 days on the state case (id.). The presentence report said U.S.S.G. § 5G1.3(b) applied and recommended adjusting the sentence for that time (id.).


The judge gave him 30 years on each count, run back to back, for 60 years total. She ordered the federal sentence to run concurrently with what remained of the state sentence (slip op. at 3). When defense counsel asked for credit for the state time, the judge answered: "I can't do that. I'll — I'll let the Bureau of Prisons do that." Counsel said the court could instead "adjust the sentence." The probation officer then said the time was being credited to the state case and should be left to the BOP (slip op. at 3–4).


Two different tools:

The Fifth Circuit explained the difference (slip op. at 7–9):


  • 18 U.S.C. § 3585(b): BOP credit. You get credit for time in official detention before your federal sentence begins, but not for time "that has not been credited against another sentence" (18 U.S.C. § 3585(b)). The BOP calculates this credit after sentencing, not the judge (United States v. Wilson, 503 U.S. 329, 333–35 (1992)). Time that already counted toward a state sentence generally can't count again here.

  • U.S.S.G. § 5G1.3(b): the judge's adjustment. This guideline applies when the other sentence comes from an offense that is relevant conduct to the federal one. In that situation, "the court shall adjust the sentence for any period of imprisonment already served on the undischarged term" that the BOP will not credit, and it runs the federal sentence concurrently with the rest of the state term (U.S.S.G. § 5G1.3(b) (Nov. 2024)). The commentary gives an example: a 13-month total punishment becomes a 7-month federal sentence because 6 months were already served on the state case (§ 5G1.3 cmt. n.2(D)).


What the court held:

The issue was preserved. Counsel never cited § 5G1.3(b) by number. But asking for "credit," a "backdate[d]" sentence, or an "adjust[ed]" sentence conveyed the "essence" of the request, and that was enough (slip op. at 5–7).


The judge mixed up the two tools. She was right that she couldn't award § 3585(b) credit. She was wrong that this kept her from considering a § 5G1.3(b) adjustment (slip op. at 9–10). Running the sentences concurrently satisfied only part (b)(2). It didn't show she had considered the adjustment in part (b)(1) (slip op. at 10–11).


Both conditions were met. The state case was undisputed relevant conduct, and the roughly 40 months were being credited to the state sentence, so the BOP couldn't credit them federally (slip op. at 12–13).


Result: The sentence was vacated and the case sent back for resentencing (slip op. at 13). The guidelines are advisory, so the judge may impose the same sentence again. In the court's words, though, "she must consider all of § 5G1.3(b) when doing so" (slip op. at 12 n.6; see United States v. Booker, 543 U.S. 220, 264 (2005), cited at slip op. 9). Judge Catharina Haynes dissented. She would have reviewed only for plain error and expected the same sentence on remand (slip op. at 14–15).


Practical steps:

  1. Before sentencing, list all your custody time and which sentence it's being credited to.

  2. Check whether the other case is relevant conduct. If it is, § 5G1.3(b) may apply (§ 5G1.3(b) & cmt. n.2(A)).

  3. Make sure the request is clear on the record. Cite § 5G1.3(b) if you can. Koan shows that the substance of the request can be enough, but naming the guideline is safer (slip op. at 5–7).

  4. Ask for the adjustment to be written into the judgment. The commentary says the judgment should name § 5G1.3(b), the amount of the adjustment, and the state term involved (§ 5G1.3 cmt. n.2(C)).

  5. Match the problem to the right forum. If the BOP miscalculates credit after sentencing, prisoners use the BOP's administrative remedy process first and seek court review only after exhausting it (Wilson, 503 U.S. at 335; 28 C.F.R. § 542.10). If the judge failed to consider § 5G1.3(b), that's a sentencing error, and it's usually raised on direct appeal, as in Koan.


Sources:


SP@NorridLaw.com   Corrlinks

816 562 4981  or  417 236 1179


Samaritan Consultants

"When No One Else Will Help, We Will!"



 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER

Cherry v. United States: a missed objection and a vacated sentence U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, No. 21-2231. Decided November 5, 2026. Opinion by Judge Sykes, joined by Judges Rovner

 
 
 
SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER

Maxwell v. Dinis, and what the justices asked about First Step Act credits Supreme Court of the United States, No. 25-5930. Argued November 2, 2026. Decision pending. William Maxwell is a federal pris

 
 
 
SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER

He Was Told 21 Years. The Real Floor Was 57 Years. A Court Said That Bad Advice Cost Him a Fair Choice. What happened: In 2010, federal prosecutors charged Steven Baker with robbing a credit union in

 
 
 

Comments


  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
bottom of page