SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER 11.23.26
Miles v. Bowers
Miles v. Bowers, No. 25-1291, 173 F.4th 372 (1st Cir. Apr. 27, 2026) (Lipez, J.); 28 C.F.R. § 523.42(a) (as amended, effective Sept. 30, 2026)
Miles was sentenced in federal court in October 2022 and again in April 2023 on two separate cases, for a total of 300 months. After his first sentencing he sat in the Marion County Jail in Indianapolis for fifteen months before the Bureau of Prisons moved him to his designated prison, FMC Devens in Massachusetts. He says he worked as a unit orderly at the jail the whole time.
The First Step Act lets eligible prisoners earn time credits for recidivism-reduction programming, and the statute lists a prison job as one kind of qualifying program. Credits start once a sentence "commences," which federal law defines as the date a person is received in custody awaiting transportation to the prison where the sentence will be served. The BOP's own regulation used a later date: the day the prisoner arrives at the designated BOP facility. On that basis the BOP gave Miles no credit for his jail work. Miles said proper credit would cut about 150 days.
Miles filed a habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2241. The magistrate judge found the BOP's rule contrary to the statute and recommended that his petition go forward, but the district judge dismissed it. The First Circuit vacated that dismissal and sent the case back. A law school appellate clinic at Georgetown represented Miles on appeal. It held:
The BOP's rule that a sentence does not commence until arrival at the designated facility is invalid. The BOP did not defend it on appeal.
The risk and needs assessment the BOP does after a prisoner arrives is not a precondition to earning credits.
A prisoner can earn credits for programming completed before that assessment, even while held outside a federal facility.
Miles may be eligible for credits for his orderly work during all fifteen months at the jail.
The government argued his clock started only at his second sentencing. The court saw no reason to treat the two periods differently. Nothing stopped the BOP from moving him to Devens and bringing him back for the later case, and eight more months passed after the second sentencing before he was transferred.
The win has limits. The court did not award Miles any credits and did not decide whether his jail job counts as qualifying programming. It held that the BOP must make an individualized decision about his work, and left the next steps to the district court. Credits also still go toward early release only for prisoners who reach and keep a minimum or low recidivism risk, and people convicted of certain listed offenses remain ineligible.
After Miles and similar rulings, the BOP changed its rule. An interim final rule published August 31, 2026, and effective September 30, 2026, deleted the "arrives at the designated facility" language. Section 523.42(a) now says an eligible inmate begins earning credits after the term of imprisonment commences. The BOP cited Miles in its explanation and said its current practice already matches the change.
Why this matters
Many people spend months in county jails after sentencing while they wait for a bed. Before this rule change, the BOP treated that time as dead time for First Step Act credit. Now the statute's start date controls, both in the First Circuit and nationwide under the amended regulation. Anyone who did work or programming while waiting for designation should gather proof now: work assignments, class certificates, and staff letters. Then ask the BOP, through the administrative remedy process, to review that time. If the BOP still refuses to look at it, a habeas petition under § 2241 is the way to bring the issue to court, as Miles did. The ruling does not guarantee credit, but the BOP can no longer reject that time just because of where it was spent.
816-562-4981 | 417-236-1179
Samaritan Consultants
"When no one else will help, we will."

Comments