top of page
Search

SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER 11.23.26

34 minutes ago
3 min read

Carter v. United States


Carter v. United States, No. 5:22-cv-8043-LCB, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 185528, 2026 WL 2389715 (N.D. Ala. Aug. 17, 2026) (Burke, J.); direct appeal, United States v. Carter, No. 18-14806, 969 F.3d 1239 (11th Cir. Aug. 12, 2020)


Carter was convicted by a federal jury in north Alabama in 2018 of possessing a firearm as a felon and of simple marijuana possession. He was sentenced as an armed career criminal to 210 months, or 17.5 years. Without that label, the maximum for the gun charge at the time was 10 years.


The Armed Career Criminal Act requires three qualifying prior convictions committed on separate occasions. Carter had three drug distribution convictions. One from 2008 was not in dispute. The fight was over two Pike County, Alabama, offenses, numbered 349 and 350, that he pleaded guilty to on the same day in 2009. One charged cocaine distribution. The other charged marijuana distribution with an enhancement for selling near a school and a public housing project.


At sentencing in 2018, Judge Blackburn relied on the state plea hearing to find that the two sales happened on different dates. Carter appealed. The Eleventh Circuit had doubts about the plea transcript but affirmed on a different ground. Because only the marijuana count carried the location enhancement, the panel reasoned the two sales most likely happened at different places and times. Then, in 2022, the Supreme Court decided Wooden v. United States, 595 U.S. 360, and expressly rejected the Eleventh Circuit's reasoning in Carter's own appeal. Wooden requires a look at the whole picture: timing, location, and how closely the offenses are connected. Carter filed a § 2255 motion in December 2022, and the court appointed counsel for him.


Judge Burke granted the motion. First, he rejected Carter's argument that a jury had to decide the occasions question. Erlinger v. United States, 602 U.S. 821 (2024), came out after Carter's conviction became final and does not apply retroactively on collateral review.


Second, he rejected the government's claim that Carter was improperly attacking his state convictions. Carter never said those convictions were invalid. He only argued that the government's evidence did not prove the offenses happened on separate occasions, and he may make that challenge.


Third, the judge agreed the plea transcript was the kind of record a court may consider, because Carter implicitly confirmed the facts by not objecting and then saying his plea was voluntary. But the transcript did not help the government. Carter repeatedly said he was pleading guilty to a cocaine charge. When the prosecutor read the factual basis, he described two marijuana sales, one in March and one in April 2009, and no cocaine sale at all. The judge said the prosecutor may have misspoken or may have read the facts of a different offense, and the court would not guess which.


That left only the indictment. The location enhancement pointed toward separate occasions, but the government conceded it is no longer enough after Wooden. Everything else pointed the other way: both were drug sales, both were charged in one indictment with back-to-back numbers, and both were prosecuted together. The government had not carried its burden. Only two of Carter's priors counted, so his ACCA sentence violated federal law. Resentencing will be set by separate order.


Why this matters

Wooden helps people whose ACCA sentences rest on priors charged together or committed close together. Carter shows how to use it. The government carries the burden of proving separate occasions with reliable and specific evidence, and a sentencing court may not fill holes in an old state record with guesses. A mistake in a plea transcript, or a record that says little about when and where crimes happened, can be enough to defeat the enhancement. One caution: Carter had fought the separate-occasions issue at sentencing and on direct appeal. The order cites the rule that a prisoner who lost an issue on appeal can bring it back under § 2255 after an intervening change in the law. Anyone with a similar claim should check what was raised earlier and talk with counsel about timing.


816-562-4981 | 417-236-1179


Samaritan Consultants

"When no one else will help, we will."


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER 11.23.26

United States v. Fernandez United States v. Fernandez, No. 10 Cr. 863 (AKH), Doc. 369 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 23, 2026) (Hellerstein, J.); see Fernandez v. United States, No. 24-556, 146 S. Ct. 1292 (U.S. May

 
 
 
SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER 11.23.26

Miles v. Bowers Miles v. Bowers, No. 25-1291, 173 F.4th 372 (1st Cir. Apr. 27, 2026) (Lipez, J.); 28 C.F.R. § 523.42(a) (as amended, effective Sept. 30, 2026) Miles was sentenced in federal court in O

 
 
 
SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER 11.22.26

United States v. Klotz United States v. Klotz, No. 4:19-cr-00366-DGK-1, ECF No. 53 (W.D. Mo. Nov. 19, 2026) (Kays, J.); 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(2); U.S.S.G. App. C, Amend. 821; U.S.S.G. § 1B1.10(d) Klotz

 
 
 

Comments


  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
bottom of page