SAMARITAN NEWSLETTER
Eleventh Circuit Vacates Denial of Compassionate Release in United States v. Spikes
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, No. 26-10132 (not for publication; per curiam). Judges Jill Pryor, Branch, and Kidd. Decided November 3, 2026. Appeal from the Middle District of Georgia, No. 7:08-cr-00007-LAG-CHW-2.
Leon Bernard Spikes, Sr. was convicted in 2009 of armed bank robbery and possessing a firearm during a crime of violence, and sentenced to 270 months (Slip op. 2). He filed several compassionate release motions. The district court denied the first in September 2022, saying § 1B1.13 had not been updated since the First Step Act and that the record did not show he had exhausted with the Bureau of Prisons. It denied the next two on similar reasoning (Slip op. 2–3). In February 2024 he filed a fourth motion, and his counsel added a supplement noting that the Sentencing Commission had amended § 1B1.13 (Slip op. 3).
The district court denied the fourth motion in an order "nearly identical to those that it issued previously" (Slip op. 3). On appeal, the Eleventh Circuit said it was unclear whether the district court found Spikes ineligible or denied relief as a matter of discretion. It assumed the latter and reviewed for abuse of discretion (Slip op. 4–5).
It found two problems. First, the district court applied a prior version of U.S.S.G. § 1B1.13. The Commission amended the policy statement effective November 1, 2023 (Amendment 814), but the order used language from before the amendment (Slip op. 5–6). Second, the order did not explain itself. Despite full briefing, "nothing in the district court's order suggests that it actually assessed Spikes's claims or the government's counterarguments," and the Eleventh Circuit could not tell which factors the court relied on (Slip op. 6). The court held these errors required vacatur and said the district court "should apply the correct version of § 1B1.13" on remand (Slip op. 6).
The disposition reads: "We VACATE the district court's order denying Spikes's compassionate release motion and REMAND this case for further proceedings consistent with this opinion" (Slip op. 7).
Why This Matters
Spikes has not received a reduction. The Eleventh Circuit did not decide that he qualifies, and the district court may rule again as long as it applies the current § 1B1.13 and explains its decision (Slip op. 6–7). For others, the case means a denial that rests on the pre-2023 policy statement can be challenged, and a cursory order that does not engage with the parties' arguments may be vacated. The opinion is unpublished and not binding precedent (Slip op. 1).
Source: United States v. Spikes, No. 26-10132 (11th Cir. Nov. 3, 2026) (per curiam) (unpublished), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-ca11-26-10132/pdf/USCOURTS-ca11-26-10132-0.pdf

Comments